One evening, Phoebe and Caleb went to a local bar to unwind. They were enjoying their drinks and reminiscing about old times when Patty walked in. After exchanging pleasantries, the conversation shifted to shared memories. Patty brought up a light-hearted incident involving Caleb at a karaoke bar, which led to a playful comment about being his “favorite girlfriend.”
Phoebe, trying to keep the conversation light while also affirming her role in Caleb’s life, responded, “Wouldn’t I be his favorite girlfriend since I’m the one he married?” Her comment was intended to highlight that, as his wife, she was the one Caleb had chosen to spend his life with.
Patty’s reaction was immediate. She finished her drink, said her goodbyes, and left the bar. Later that evening, Caleb received a lengthy message from Patty expressing her hurt feelings. Patty was upset, feeling that Phoebe’s comment was a reflection of jealousy and insecurity. She mentioned that Phoebe seemed to be dismissing the significance of her own past with Caleb.
